Joel
Pietila
Professor
Westblade
REL
319
2/19/2018
New England History 1720s
As the decade preceding the
beginning of the First Great Awakening, in many respects, the 1720s marked the beginning
of certain eras and the end of others in the New England colony. With increased
immigration from Great Britain, natural phenomena, the beginning of an
important man’s ministry, and a war, the decade presented many challenges and
transitions for the colony to work through. The result of such events and
transitions set the stage for the First Great Awakening to take place.
In the 1720s, New England saw a
large influx of immigrants enter the colony from Great Britain. Harry Stout
provides an example of the major growth in his The New England Soul when he says, “In Connecticut, new parishes
were partitioned off at an average rate of seventeen per decade throughout 18th
century, with a high point of twenty-three new societies incorporated in the
decade 1721-1730” (Stout 163). With many new congregations forming in short
periods of time, new ministers needed to be ready to lead them. The problem
before New England during this overwhelming immigration existed, as Stout
explains, in establishing pastors with “binding congregational covenants”
(Stout 163) in order to preserve “New England’s place as ‘Emmanuel’s Land’” (Stout
163). The colony not only needed conformity from these immigrants, but more
importantly, it needed the church to continue to be central to society to advance
New England’s mission to be the modern people of Israel. In fact, although the
colony grew in population, “By the 1720s, New England church membership
appeared to decline in proportion to natural population increase and
immigration” (Smith 88-89). As a result of immigration factors and a
declination of church attendance, Jonathan Edwards noted and preached against
the sharp decline in public and private morals within New England (Smith 89).
The threat to the idea of New
England taking the form of a modern Israel stretched beyond a decline in church
membership and morality. The other major force of contention came from east of
New England, a Native American tribe known as the Wabanakis. New Englanders had
a particular hatred for this tribe of people, caused by countless attacks and
worries that the Wabanakis inflicted (Protestant 93). One particular example
was the capture of Reverend John Williams’ family in 1704. As Thomas Kidd
describes in The Protestant Interest, John
Williams’ daughter Eunice “never returned, marrying a Kahnawake man and
converting to Catholicism” (Protestant 93). The real threat that came with the
Wabanakis was the fact that they were supported by French Catholicism, led by
Sebastian Rale, a French Jesuit who sparked much controversy between the Indian
tribe and the New Englanders (Protestant 95-96). Rale had played a role in the
American colonies for thirty years, first coming over to evangelize to the
Indians in 1689 (Protestant 95).
In 1720, in an attempt to end the
feud with the Wabanakis, as well as buffer the French threat, Governor Robert
Ashurst advised the New Englanders to partake in more mission’s efforts to
convert the Indians, as well as show respect to their land rights (Protestant
99). Unfortunately, the request fell on mostly deaf ears, with Samuel Sewall
and Solomon Stoddard having been some of the only New England leaders to take
this request seriously (Protestant 100). Instead, increased tensions between
New England and the Wabanakis resulted in a declaration of war by Governor
Shute in July 1722, because of a retaliation from the Indians, which resulted
from “a failed attempt to seize Rale” (Protestant 101). This declaration marked
the beginning of what would become known as the Father Rale’s War. The war was
narrated and publicized, according to Kidd, “as a new episode in the European
and North American battle between Catholicism and Protestantism” (Protestant
102).
The outbreak of the war had intense
opposition from prominent church leaders, especially Solomon Stoddard, who
argued that cooperation was attainable with the Indians if the New Englanders would
only refocus their efforts on sharing the good news with the Indians instead of
defeating them. Stoddard referenced the terrible truth, according to the New
Englanders, that Catholics had evangelized much more effectively to the Indians
all over the New World and caused the Protestants to look particularly bad
(Protestant 105-106). Despite Stoddard’s efforts, the war continued. The
beginning of the end in this war came in August 1724, when Massachusetts forces
completed an expedition on Norridgewock, the heart of Sebastian Rale’s
campaign, which resulted in many deaths of Indians and the killing of Rale
(Protestant 107 and American 191). Cotton Mather, a Boston Minister at the
time, thought “there was no doubt that the French Jesuit and Satan were in a
league against New England” (Protestant 108). Mather insisted that the death of
Rale was a victory in holding on to Protestant principles. The war continued
for another year, with the French seeking revenge for what they perceived as a
martyrdom of Rale. Kidd describes, however, that “it seemed that the death of
Rale and the fatigue of the Wabanakis led to the war’s end” (Protestant 112),
and a peace treaty was signed in November 1725 (Protestant 112). The war
brought fear to the New Englanders, who were “deeply concerned with their place
in the contests of empire and the worldwide battle for the fate of
Christianity” (Protestant 113), and yet the ministers found the constant strife
unsurprising (Protestant 114).
The 1720s presented multiple
threats to the advancement of the New England’s vision of being Emmanual’s
Land, and the ministers and preachers needed revival of Christianity in order
to continue its mission. Perhaps coincidentally, hope was closer than it may
have seemed, and came in an unexpected manner. On October 29th,
1727, late into the night, “New England awoke to the most convulsive earthquake
in living memory” (Stout 165). What began with “a flash of Light” (Stout 165)
finished with groups huddled in the middle of streets sure that the day of
judgement had come (Stout 165). The aftermath of the earthquake could not have
boded more perfectly for the New England ministers and leaders. Harry Stout
describes the earthquake as the catalyst to “bring the whole country to the
churches” (Stout 165). With all of the townspeople and new attendees searching
for answers, congregational ministers provided the answer, which was simple:
the end times are near. In fact, the earthquake happened the same night as an
end times sermon was preached by Nathaniel Gookin from Hampton (Stout 165).
Both Cotton and Increase Mather spent much of their preaching lives working on
predicting when the end would come (Protestant 147). The earthquake only
intensified their convictions. Although their predictions were incorrect,
increased emphasis on missions and evangelism, as well as massive numbers of
conversions preceding the Second Coming of Christ, gave new hope for New
England (Protestant 157). Kidd explains that the earthquake “led to many
conversions and further speculations about great numbers of conversions at the
end of time” (Protestant 162). The earthquake seemed to start a chain of revivals
and revivalist efforts in preparation for the end of the world.
The original revivalists from New
England had a specific goal in mind as revivals continued to take place all
around their colony. Smith states, “it was a fundamentalist, early seventeen-century
form of Calvinism that the revivalists who arose in the late 1720s and early
1730s sought to restore and hoped would redefine all of American Christianity”
(Smith 57). In other words, revivalists in New England hoped to bring the
colony, and more broadly, the entire country, back to Puritan lifestyle and
restore the title of Emmanual’s Land. Perhaps not so coincidentally, Jonathan
Edwards took over the Northampton church in February 1728/29 from Solomon
Stoddard (Smith 52). Edwards, who not only experienced a revival in his own
life, but also witnessed many conversion experiences first hand (Rivett 278),
would lead the revivalist movement into the 1730s. Considering all that
transpired in New England leading up to Edwards, one might say, the harvest was
ripe when he took the pulpit.
Works Cited
Kidd, Thomas S. American Colonial History: Clashing Cultures and Faiths. Yale University Press, 2016.
Kidd, Thomas S. The Protestant Interest: New England After Puritanism. Yale University Press, 2004.
Rivett, Sarah. The Science of the Soul in Colonial New England. University of North Carolina Press, 2011.
Smith, John Howard. The First Great Awakening: Redefining Religion in British America, 1725-1775. Fairleigh Dickinson University Press, 2015, pp. 1–357.
Stout, Harry S. The New England Soul: Preaching and Religious Culture in Colonial New England. Oxford University Press, 2012.